Search This Blog

SuperTarts Review (Review Complete 6/10/15!)



Vendor: Supertarts

Review Author: Lindsay Sara
Order Placed: February 23, 2015
Order Received: April 23, 2015

Pre-Review/Post Order:
  • Products
    • Wax Clamshells
    • Body Butters
    • Sugar Scrubs
    • Face Mask

  • Where to Order: http://supertarts.bigcartel.com/

  • Availability: This vendor generally opens once a month for 3 – 5 days.

  • Turn Around Time (TAT): 6 to 7 weeks

  • Price: $$$$

  • Cure Time: Vendor says no cure time is necessary. I will be waiting approximately one month just to be sure!

  • Warmer Recommended: 20-24 watt hot plate warmers.

  • My Order:
    • Else (Clamshell)
-         Cotton Candy Ice Cream
    • Grey’s Anatomy (Clamshell)
-         Starbucks Coffee, Vanilla Ice Cream, and Creamy Pecan Pie
    • PF Changs (Clamshell)
-         Flaky Pecan Rugalach cookies dusted with a hint of cinnamon, warm creamy Challah bread and a buttery brown sugar.
    • Wicked (Clamshell)
-         Pistachio, Toasted Marshmallow, Signature Sugar Cookies

  • Extra Love Received:
    • Sixlets (Candy)

  • Picture of Order/Products






  • Wax Look:
    • Absolutely freaking adorable! Almost too cute to melt!
 

  • Cold Smell:
    • Elsa
-         An artificial cotton candy smell.

    • Grey’s Anatomy
-         All I can smell in this scent is the Starbucks coffee. I am not a huge fan of Starbucks coffee because I think the beans are overcooked, and it always smells burnt. I am hoping the other aspects of this blend overpower the burnt coffee scent.

    • PF Changs
-         This scent kind of reminds me of the popular pumpkin pecan waffles scent. It has bakery notes and hints of maple and cinnamon.

    • Wicked
-         A sweet soap like scent.


Wax Melting Review: 
  • Detailed Description of Each Smell:
    • Elsa
-         Although weak, the only scent that came through on this particular scent was that artificial cotton candy smell.

    • Grey’s Anatomy
-         A light coffee scent with subtle sweet bakery notes.

    • PF Changs
-         A light sweet pastry like scent. Subtle notes of cinnamon and possibly maple.

    • Wicked
-         I couldn’t smell anything other than a very subtle hint of that soapy like scent I smelled on cold smell.

  • Comparison to Cold Smell
    • Elsa
-         Similar

    • Grey’s Anatomy
-         Similar, but not as intense of a burnt coffee scent.

    • PF Changs
-         Similar

    • Wicked
-         Similar

  • Scent Throw:
    • Elsa
-         1

    • Grey’s Anatomy
-         2

    • PF Changs
-         1

    • Wicked
-         1


Sum Up:
  • Overall Impression
    • I have heard a lot about this vendor. I have to say she has some awesomely creative blends and I love her themes. The look of her wax is just as creative as her blends. Unfortunately, this vendor will not be earning a spot in my wax collection. I felt as if some of the scents were very artificial, and those that I did like were simply not strong enough for me.

  • Pros
    • Creative Blends
    • Beautiful Looking!
    • Although the wax is highly sought after, it is not impossible to get a hold of.

  • Cons
    • Not all scents available at all restocks.
    • Scents do not have an incredibly strong throw.

  • Overall Liked Scents
    • Grey’s Anatomy
    • PF Changs

  • Overall Disliked Scents
    • Wicked
    • Elsa

  • If it ends up in a destash, why?
    • Grey’s Anatomy
-         Not strong enough.
    • PF Changs
-         Not strong enough.
    • Wicked
-         Not strong enough.
    • Elsa
-         Not strong enough, and I wasn’t a fan of the cotton candy scent oil used.

  • How the wax could be improved?/Was it missing something?
    • Overall, the wax throw needs to be improved.
    • Some of the scent oils used came off as artificial, such as the scent oils used for Wicked.

  • Was it worth the money?
    • Not really.

  •  Would I purchase from this vendor again?
    • Probably not. Although I liked some of the scents, the throw left a lot to be desired.

6 comments:

  1. Strange. My supertarts including Pf Changs are ridiculous strong

    ReplyDelete
  2. It could be a product consistency issue. I had to literally stand over it to smell it. The more popular a vendor gets, the more products they make to meet demand. Unfortunately, quality and consistency of quality generally takes a hit when this happens.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For me ST is the absolute strongest vendor around, but I do find you have to use a 20 wall hot plate or bulb warmer. If I use a 24 watt hot plate I can't smell a thing hardly. While ST isn't at the top of my list as far as scents it is the top as far as strength and throw.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Everyone has different experiences. I have friends who love Supertarts, so much so I have considered giving it another try. All wax should throw in a 24 watt warmer. It may not throw as long, but it is the highest wattage and therefore the hottest. I generally test in multiple warmers, I use a glade 20 watt, 24 watt mainstays, and a tealight warmer. The issue I have is consistency. Some I've heard throws well (from the friends who love Supertarts), others don't (heard from the same friends). I don't want only some of my money to be well spent. I think this is why personally I've had trouble with giving Supertarts another try. It also seems more popular which makes accessibility more tricky. Everyone has a different experience, and this was mine. I welcome feedback because in all honesty, I can't review everything and I am just one person providing one person's experience.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Have you tried Domestic Designs yet?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have not. I took a break from reviewing once I started my nursing career, but hope to get back to it.

      Delete